Normal view

Received before yesterday

Petition for Truing up and determination of the transmission tariff for Combined Asset under “Northern Region System Strengthening Scheme-XV” – EQ

Summary:

### **1. PROCEEDINGS & COMMISSION’S DIRECTIONS**

After hearing PGCIL’s representatives, the Commission issued the following procedural directions:

**A. Timeline for Submissions:**
1. **Respondents** (State Utilities) to file their **replies within two weeks**, with an advance copy to PGCIL.
2. **PGCIL** may file its **rejoinder within two weeks** thereafter.

**B. Specific Information Sought from PGCIL (on Affidavit within two weeks):**
The Commission directed PGCIL to provide detailed, asset-specific information for most petitions. The **common themes** across the data requests are:

1. **Detailed Cost Breakdowns:**
* **Item-wise unit cost** for claimed Additional Capital Expenditure (ACE) related to asset replacement.
* **Element-wise/Party-wise break-up** of capital costs (as on 31.3.2019) and claimed ACE.

2. **Historical Comparison & Justification:**
* **Comparison tables** showing ACE **allowed in previous tariff orders vs. claimed now** for 2019-24, with justifications for any variations.
* **Reconciliation of cost overruns** (e.g., Petition 525/TT/2025 notes a variation of ₹1117.53 lakh).

3. **Regulatory Form Compliance:**
* Submission of specific **Forms (e.g., Form-5, 7B, 9C, 9E, 13)** related to plant & machinery cost, depreciation, and tariff calculations for both 2019-24 and 2024-29 periods.

4. **Technical & Economic Justification for Future Capex (2024-29):**
* **Basis, technical justification, and cost-benefit analysis** for ACE/De-capitalization claimed under **Regulation 25(2) of the 2024 Tariff Regulations**.

5. **Supporting Documentation:**
* **Certificates of obsolescence** from OEMs or competent authorities for replaced equipment.
* **Minutes of relevant committee meetings** approving projects (e.g., NERPC/TCC for Kumarghat substation in Petition 539/TT/2025).
* **Liquidated damages recovery statements** and **initial spares discharge statements**.

### **2. KEY BUSINESS & REGULATORY IMPLICATIONS**

* **Regulatory Scrutiny:** The Commission is conducting a **detailed, granular review** of PGCIL’s capital expenditures, both past (truing up) and future (tariff determination). The focus is on **prudence, justification, and cost-effectiveness**.
* **Focus on ACE:** A significant portion of the inquiry revolves around **Additional Capital Expenditure (ACE)**, indicating scrutiny of project cost overruns, replacements, and upgrades.
* **Transparency & Accountability:** The directives emphasize **transparency** through standardized formats (tables, forms), comparisons with past approvals, and demand for third-party certificates (OEM).
* **Procedure:** The process follows a standard regulatory timeline: **Petition → Hearing → Directions for Information → Respondent’s Reply → Rejoinder → Final Order**.
* **Subject Matter:** The petitions cover a wide range of transmission assets—from system strengthening schemes to project-specific systems—highlighting PGCIL’s ongoing role in national grid development and the subsequent periodic tariff resets.
* **Next Steps:** The matters are **reserved for order** after compliance with the above directions. The final tariff orders will determine the revenue PGCIL can recover from beneficiary states for using these transmission assets for the next five years.

For more information please see below link:

Petition for Truing up and determination of transmission tariff for the Combined Asset under “Integration of Pooling Stations in Chhattisgarh with Central Part of the Western Region for IPP Generation Projects – EQ

Summary:

—-

### **1. Overview and Context:**
– **Date of Hearing:** 13th January 2026.
– **Common Petitioner:** Power Grid Corporation of India Limited (PGCIL).
– **Subject:** Multiple petitions (listed below) for **truing up of tariffs for the 2019-24 period** and **determination of tariffs for the 2024-29 period** for various transmission assets across India.
– **Regulatory Framework:** Petitions filed under the relevant tariff regulations (e.g., CERC Tariff Regulations, 2019).

### **2. List of Petitions & Key Respondents:**
The petitions involve transmission schemes across different regions. Key respondents are primarily the state power distribution companies (DISCOMs) of the respective beneficiary states.

| Petition No. | Scheme/Project Name | Region | Key Respondent(s) |
| :— | :— | :— | :— |
| **924/TT/2025** | Integration of Pooling Stations in Chhattisgarh… | Western | MPPMCL & 5 Others |
| **926/TT/2025** | System Strengthening XXVI | Southern | TANGEDCO/TNPDCL & 13 Others |
| **921/TT/2025** | System Strengthening Scheme-XIII | Southern | TANGEDCO/TNPDCL & 13 Others |
| **920/TT/2025** | Transmission System for Pavagada Solar Park Phase-I | Southern | TANGEDCO/TNPDCL & 13 Others |
| **962/TT/2025** | Substation works beyond Vemagiri | Southern | TANGEDCO/TNPDCL & 14 Others |
| **964/TT/2025** | WR-NR Corridor for Chhattisgarh IPPs | Northern | UPPCL & 21 Others |
| **413/TT/2025** | North Eastern Region Strengthening Scheme-IV | North Eastern | APDCL & 6 Others |
| **435/TT/2025** | Inter-Regional Strengthening (WR & NR Part-A) | Inter-Regional | MPPMCL & 5 Others |
| **411/TT/2025** | Raipur-Rajnandgaon TL for Chhattisgarh IPPs | Western | MPPMCL & 8 Others |
| **518/TT/2025** | Transmission for Phase-I Gen Projects in Odisha | Western | MPPMCL & 5 Others |
| **420/TT/2025** | Western Region System Strengthening Scheme-V | Western | MPPMCL & 5 Others |
| **731/TT/2025** | *(Details not fully specified in snippet)* | *Not Specified* | *Not Specified* |

### **3. Proceedings and Core Issue:**
– PGCIL, as the Central Transmission Utility (CTU), is seeking **regulatory approval for the final tariffs** for its transmission assets.
– The process involves two key steps for each asset:
1. **Truing Up (2019-24):** Final reconciliation of actual capital expenditure (CAPEX) and operational costs against earlier estimates to determine the final payable tariff for the past period.
2. **Tariff Determination (2024-29):** Setting the approved tariff for the next regulatory period based on the trued-up capital cost and normative operational parameters.

### **4. Business & Regulatory Implications:**

– **For PGCIL:** This is a critical, routine regulatory process to **secure revenue recovery** for its vast transmission investments. Timely and accurate submission of the voluminous data is essential to avoid delays in tariff approval and cash flow.
– **For Respondent DISCOMs:** They have the opportunity to **review and challenge** PGCIL’s cost claims. Their scrutiny is vital to ensure that only prudent and efficient costs are passed through to the end consumers via tariffs.
– **For End Consumers:** The outcome of these petitions will ultimately influence the **transmission component of electricity bills** for consumers in the beneficiary states.
– **For the Power Sector:** The process underscores the **regulated, cost-plus nature of transmission tariffs** in India. It ensures transparency and allows recovery of investments for critical national grid infrastructure.

—-

For more information please see below link:

Petition for Truing up and determination of the transmission tariff for “Transmission System of Vindhyachal-IV & Rihand-III (1000 MW) Generation Project” in the Western Region – EQ

Summary:

**1. Overview of Petitions**
All three petitions filed by **Power Grid Corporation of India Limited (PGCIL)** seek:
– **Truing up** of transmission tariff for the period **2019–24**.
– **Determination** of transmission tariff for the period **2024–29**.

**2. Petition-wise Summary**

| Petition No. | Scheme / Asset Description | Region | Key Respondents |
|————–|—————————-|——–|——————|
| 1021/TT/2025 | Transmission System for **Vindhyachal-IV & Rihand-III (1000 MW) Generation Project** | Western Region | MPPMCL & 20 others |
| 925/TT/2025 | Transmission System for **Ultra Mega Solar Park in Anantapur, AP – Part A (Phase-I)** | Southern Region | TANGEDCO (TNPDCL) & 14 others |
| 731/TT/2025 | **400 kV S/C Singrauli–Vindhyachal TL** with **(2×250 MW) HVDC Back-to-Back at Vindhyachal (NR-WR)** | Inter-regional | UPPCL & 20 others |

**3. Key Proceedings & Directions from CERC**

– **No replies received** from respondents in any of the three petitions.
– **Fresh notices** to be issued to all respondents.
– **Respondents** given **2 weeks** to file replies; **PGCIL** may file rejoinder within **1 week** thereafter.
– **Next hearing date:** 17 February 2026 at 2:30 PM.

**4. Specific Information/Documents Directed by CERC**

**A. For Petition No. 1021/TT/2025:**
1. **Element-wise capital cost breakdown** (Land, Buildings, Transmission Line, Substation, PLCC, IT, etc.) as of 31.03.2019.
2. **Form 9C** in Excel for both tariff periods.
3. **Liability Flow Statement** in Excel.
4. **Asset-wise LD (Liquidated Damages) recovery details**.
5. **Form 7B** for both periods.
6. **Cumulative depreciation details** for IT & PLCC as of 31.03.2019.

**B. For Petition No. 925/TT/2025:**
1. **Justification for variation** in opening capital cost vs. previous order.
2. **Initial Spares discharge statement**.
3. **Form 5 & Form 13**.
4. **Liability Flow Statements** in Excel.
5. **Form 9C** with proper linkages.
6. **Interest rate calculations** for each loan.
7. **Reconciliation of CFA (Central Financial Assistance) grant** – received, deployed, balance.
8. **Documentary proof of CFA grant utilization**.
9. **Evidence of asset decommissioning**.
10. **Justification for ACE (Additional Capital Expenditure) beyond cut-off date**.
11. **Form 7B** for both periods.

**C. For Petition No. 731/TT/2025:**
1. **Basis, technical justification & cost-benefit analysis** for ACE claimed.
2. **Liability Flow Statements for ACE**.
3. **Justification for variation in ACE vs. previous order**.
4. **Details of spillover works** from 2019–24 to 2024–29 with delay justification.
5. **Form 7B** for both periods.
6. **Clarification on IDC (Interest During Construction)** adjustments previously disallowed.

**5. Key Business & Regulatory Implications**
– **Transparency & Scrutiny:** CERC ensuring rigorous validation of capital costs, grants, and expenditures.
– **Stakeholder Engagement:** Despite no replies, fresh notices indicate emphasis on participatory regulation.
– **Renewable Integration:** Petition 925/TT/2025 relates to solar park evacuation – critical for green energy.
– **Inter-regional Assets:** Petition 731/TT/2025 involves HVDC link between NR & WR – strategic for grid stability.
– **Financial Discipline:** Detailed requirements on LD, ACE, IDC, and grants ensure accountable use of capital.

—-

For more information please see below link:

Petition for Truing up and determination of transmission tariff for “Integration of Pooling Stations with Central Part of the Western Region for IPP Generation Projects in Chhattisgarh” – EQ

v

Sumamry:

**1. Regulatory Authority**
Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC), New Delhi.

**2. Overview of Petitions**
A **combined proceeding** covering **11 separate tariff petitions** filed by **Power Grid Corporation of India Limited (PGCIL)** for truing up of transmission tariffs for the period **2019–24** and determination of tariffs for **2024–29**.

**3. Common Objective Across All Petitions**
– **Truing Up:** Adjust past tariffs (2019–24) based on actual capital expenditure, operational expenses, and other cost variations.
– **Tariff Determination:** Set new transmission tariffs for the next control period (2024–29) for specified transmission assets/schemes.

**5. Commission’s Directions & Information Requirements**
CERC directed PGCIL to submit detailed financial and technical data in prescribed formats for each petition, including:

– **Form 9C:** Capital cost, financing, and tariff calculation sheets with Excel linkages.
– **Form 7B:** Asset-wise tariff computation.
– **Form 5 & 13:** Asset details, capital expenditure, and initial spares.
– **Liability Flow Statements:** Debt and interest details.
– **IDC (Interest During Construction) Discharge Statements.**
– **Auditor Certificates:** For plant & machinery cost, initial spares.
– **Accumulated Depreciation Details:** For PLCC, IT equipment, etc.
– **ACE (Additional Capital Expenditure) Reconciliation:** Item-wise and party-wise comparison with previous orders.

**6. Key Regulatory & Business Implications**
– **Tariff Stability:** The process ensures predictable and cost-reflective transmission pricing for the next 5 years.
– **Cost Recovery:** PGCIL seeks to recover past under/over-recoveries and secure revenue for future operations.
– **Transparency:** Extensive data submission ensures regulatory scrutiny and stakeholder confidence.
– **Multi-Regional Impact:** Tariffs affect multiple state DISCOMs and power utilities across India.
– **Renewable Integration:** Some schemes (e.g., Pavagada Solar Park) support renewable energy evacuation.

—-

For more information please see below link:

❌